In the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, written by Zora Neale Hurston, one independent woman, Janie, is in conflict with the very society that she lives in. It is her outspoken and rather independent manner that causes those around her to quietly judge her as she goes about her day. Needless to say, the path that Janie has chosen to walk brings about misfortune a one after the other her relationships fail and she is left alone with no one to love except for herself.
At the start of the novel the reader could already determine Janie’s place in society. As a middle age African American woman, she held no power but something about Janie made her stand out from others of her kind and ultimately was the root of her problems. Janie’s looks brought around men that tried their best to tie her down.
The first of these suitors was a man named Logan. He was Janie’s first love but couldn’t put up with her outspoken personality. Though at times Janie would keep her mouth shut, when she finally berated the man she fled, running off with the next smooth talking man to come around her. This was the character of Jody, whose confidence impressed her, thus leading her into another broken relationship and starting chatter among the people that she had come to know for leaving her husband without so much as a word.
Their personalities clashed. Jody’s cruel and conceited demeanor caused many issues between Janie and him. His general disinterest in Janie as a human being caused the two of them to clash at every turn. Janie’s independent traits once more caused a relationship to crumble before her as her husband eventually passed on, while all in the new town that she took up residence in passed judgment upon her, saying that it was her that brought about Jody’s death.
The society in which Janie lives disapprove of the person that she is and always will be. Her independence threatens those around her that hope to hold some place of power or any authority over her very well being. The people around her reject her because of this fact, leaving her with only one friend who still speak with while all other gossip about her past relationships on their porches.

Laaaauuuuweeeen :)
ReplyDeleteI read this book in freshman year and did everything I could to forget it, but this essay kind of made me remember some of it :P
Anyway, I think the idea of linking Janie's failed relationships with society's expectations of her was smart, but my question is, "And what?" Like I see what you're saying here, about how Janie's personality put men off because they, being part of typical society, expected her to be less proud or whatever. But I think that if you better established the society (like I don't think you mentioned when or where this all takes place) you could talk more about the social implications of her relationship and what it meant for her as a woman not to have a man in that older patriarchal society.
But yeah, like I said, good starting point :)
Girl who breaks headbands!! D:
ReplyDeleteI totally never knew this book existed but it sounds so dramatic!! I think one thing you could have added is what kind of conflict she had with society. Something small :p
I do think it is very interesting though! I read the whooole thing :D
Good job!
YEARBOOK! *throws down shirt/towel/anything in hand*
Lauren!
ReplyDeleteLike ari, i've never heard of this book in my life! But you made it sound very appealing in this essay =) It was very straight forward and I liked how you incorporated the plot while making your arguements. She sounds like a really strong character! Like me! Kidding. Great job! =]
Amy